The Essential Evidence You Need to Gather for a Liability Claim

Topics > Evidence You Need to Gather

When something goes wrong and you believe someone else is at fault, your success hinges on the evidence. Think of evidence as the raw materials to build your case. Without it, you have only a story. With strong evidence, you have a credible claim. The goal is to collect anything that objectively shows what happened, who was responsible, and how you were harmed. Start gathering immediately, as memories fade and physical proof can disappear.

First and foremost, document the scene. If it is safe to do so, take comprehensive photographs and videos from multiple angles and distances. Capture the specific hazard—the cracked sidewalk, the spilled liquid, the broken step, the malfunctioning equipment. Get wide shots that show the context and close-ups that show the detail. If there are any visible injuries, photograph them as well, and continue to document their healing process over time. Do not rely on your memory; the camera is your most reliable witness.

Next, identify and secure any physical evidence related to the incident. This might be the defective product that caused injury, the torn piece of clothing from a fall, or the damaged part from a car. If it is practical and safe, preserve it exactly as it was after the event. Do not clean it, repair it, or throw it away. For incidents on business property, ask for a copy of the incident report they create, but understand it is their version of events. Your own documentation is critical.

Witness information is gold. Get the names and contact details of anyone who saw what happened. Their independent accounts can be powerful support for your version of events. If possible, ask them to write down what they saw in their own words while it is fresh in their mind. People move on and forget, so securing their information quickly is vital. Do not argue with or coach witnesses; just get their information.

Your own medical records are non-negotiable evidence of your harm. Seek medical attention promptly, even for seemingly minor injuries. Tell the doctor exactly how the injury occurred and report all your symptoms. The medical report created at that time creates a direct, time-stamped link between the incident and your injuries. Follow all treatment plans and keep detailed records of all medical visits, prescriptions, therapies, and receipts. This documents both the severity of your injury and your financial losses.

Finally, keep a detailed and consistent personal journal. Start it the day of the incident. Record everything you remember about what happened, the pain you experience, how your injuries affect your daily life and work, and all related conversations you have with insurance companies, property owners, or employers. Note missed workdays, family events you cannot attend, and everyday tasks that are now difficult. This journal creates a continuous narrative that demonstrates the ongoing impact of the incident, far beyond what medical bills alone can show.

Gathering evidence is not about building a dramatic case; it is about methodically establishing facts. The party you claim is responsible, and their insurance company, will investigate thoroughly. Your job is to meet their scrutiny with organized, clear, and contemporaneous proof. By systematically collecting scene documentation, physical evidence, witness accounts, medical records, and a personal impact journal, you transform your claim from an allegation into a supported fact. This evidence forms the foundation upon which everything else rests.

Search

Topics

Recent Articles

When Someone Says You Harmed Them: Understanding Liability Claims

How to Submit a Formal Insurance Claim Form

What Is a Liability Claim?

Tags

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I talk to them or their lawyer directly to explain?

No. You should not communicate directly with the person making the claim or their attorney once a formal claim is made. All communication should go through your insurance company’s claims adjuster or your own attorney. Speaking directly can lead to you accidentally saying something that could be interpreted as admitting fault or liability. It can also undermine the formal process. Let the professionals handle the negotiation and discussion to protect your interests.

A broad medical release allows the adjuster to access your entire medical history, which may be used to argue your injuries are pre-existing. A quick, early settlement is often far less than your claim’s full value, especially before you reach maximum medical improvement. Once you sign a settlement, you permanently give up your right to seek more money, even if hidden injuries or costs emerge later.

You are responsible if your negligence caused the dangerous condition. This means you knew or should have known about a hazard—like a broken step, icy walkway, or wet floor—and failed to fix it or warn visitors about it in a reasonable time. Simply owning the property where someone falls does not automatically make you liable. The key question is whether you acted with reasonable care to keep your property safe for guests, customers, or other expected visitors.

The dog’s owner is almost always the primary party held responsible. In many states, specific “dog bite statutes” make the owner automatically liable if their dog injures someone, regardless of the animal’s past behavior. Even in states without such laws, the owner can be held liable if they were negligent, such as by letting a dangerous dog run loose. In some cases, a property landlord or a dog keeper (like a walker or sitter) could also share responsibility if their actions contributed to the incident.