Who Pays for Damage from Trees or Fixtures After a Hit-and-Run?

Topics > Damage from Trees or Fixtures

When a driver crashes into your property—like a tree, fence, mailbox, or light post—and then flees, you are left with a damaged fixture and a frustrating question: who pays for this? The situation is a hit-and-run, but with property, not a person. Navigating the aftermath requires clear, direct steps to protect your rights and your wallet.

Your first action must be to call the police immediately. File an official report. This creates a legal record of the incident, which is non-negotiable for any insurance claim or potential investigation. Do not clean up or repair anything until you have documented the scene thoroughly. Take extensive photographs and videos from multiple angles, showing the damage, any skid marks, and debris left behind. If you or anyone else saw the vehicle, note the color, make, model, or even a partial license plate number to give to the police. This evidence is crucial.

Next, you must contact your own insurance company. This is typically your primary path for compensation. Review your homeowner’s insurance policy or your auto insurance policy if the damaged item is a car or a structure attached to your garage. Homeowner’s insurance generally covers damage to structures on your property, like fences, sheds, or light posts, often subject to your deductible. The coverage for a tree can be more specific; your policy may cover removal of the fallen tree if it hit a covered structure, like your house, but might not cover the tree’s value if it was merely ornamental. Be prepared to provide the police report number and all your evidence to your insurer.

A critical question is whether the driver is found. If the police locate the at-fault driver, you can pursue a claim against their auto liability insurance for your property damage. This is the ideal scenario, as it should cover your repair costs without you paying your own deductible. However, hit-and-run drivers are often not found. If they are uninsured or unidentified, your own insurance coverage options come into play. If you have “uninsured motorist property damage” coverage on your auto policy, it may apply here, but this varies significantly by state. For fixtures, your homeowner’s insurance remains your primary resource.

Do not delay in taking these steps. Insurance companies require prompt reporting, and evidence can quickly disappear. While dealing with a hit-and-run is aggravating, a methodical approach is your best tool. Secure the scene, involve law enforcement, document everything, and engage your insurer directly to understand what your policies will cover. This direct action moves you from victim to claimant, putting you in the strongest position to recover your financial loss.

Search

Topics

Recent Articles

The Essential Evidence You Need to Gather for a Liability Claim

How to Know if a Settlement Offer is Fair

How Settlement Negotiations Actually Work

Tags

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Are photos from my smartphone good enough for a legal claim?

Yes, photos from a modern smartphone are perfectly acceptable and highly effective. Ensure your phone’s date and time stamps are correct, as this metadata is automatically recorded. Use the highest resolution setting and ensure images are clear and in focus. Avoid using filters or editing the photos. The authenticity of the original, unaltered image file is what makes it compelling evidence for investigators and insurance adjusters.

First, ensure everyone’s safety and document the scene thoroughly with photos and videos from multiple angles. Notify your homeowner’s insurance company immediately to report the incident—do not admit fault. Then, provide a polite, basic notice to the affected neighbor, but avoid making detailed statements about cause or liability. Promptly mitigate further damage (e.g., tarping a roof) but do not perform permanent repairs or remove major evidence before an insurance adjuster or expert can inspect.

The first offer is almost always a low initial bid, not a final evaluation of your claim’s full value. Insurers aim to close claims quickly and cheaply before all long-term costs (like future medical needs or lasting disability) are fully known. Accepting it usually requires signing a full release, forever giving up your right to seek more money later, even if your condition worsens. Having a lawyer negotiate ensures all current and future losses are accounted for.

Medical bills serve as a primary measure of the economic damages in your claim. They provide a tangible dollar amount for the cost of your care, which forms the foundation for calculating a settlement. Higher, justified bills typically increase the potential value of your claim. However, the final value also includes non-economic damages like pain and suffering, which are often calculated as a multiple of your total medical costs, making accurate and complete billing critical.